Digby at Hullabaloo has an interesting post regarding American attitudes toward Israel. She starts by quoting Dan Pfeiffer who discusses polling that shows that “strong majorities of Americans have negative views of Israel and Netanyahu”. This is a great change from just a short time ago, a reaction to the fact that like a country with a certain orange man as its putative leader, Israel has begun to engage in acts very much resembling those in which a certain European country engaged in the 1930s and 1940s. Pfeiffer writes:
According to an NBC poll, positive views of Israel have dropped 15 points since 2023, in the immediate aftermath of the October 7th terrorist attack. The shift is driven primarily by Democrats, but it goes much further than that. Support among independents is down 19 points, and even among Republicans, it’s dropped 9 points.
Pew found that strong majorities of Americans have negative views of Israel and Netanyahu. This is not just a Democratic phenomenon — a majority of adults under 50 now rate Israel and Netanyahu negatively.
Bibi Netanyahu and the genocide in Gaza have done untold damage to Israel’s standing in the United States. Only a few years ago, Israel was seen as one of our closest allies. Now, many Americans view it as a pariah state. That has real implications for American politics. While many Democrats have spoken out, the leadership — particularly Senator Schumer — has been reluctant to, clinging to an outdated view of the U.S.-Israel relationship. Politicians who don’t grasp this seismic shift risk being out of touch with the electorate in both parties. Israel is yet another issue where there’s a yawning gap between the base and the establishment.
Both Pfeiffer and Digby point out that it’s important that the Democrats strongly make the case that opposing Israel’s current incarnation is the right thing to do and has nothing to do with anti-Semitism. That can be done assuming the Democrats come up with a coherent argument that they use consistently.
Naturally, the Democrats will likely fail to stick together and make a coherent case for opposing Israel’s actions, though it does appear that a large number of elected Democrats have seen the light. Recently, a resolution proposed by Bernie Sanders, who himself is Jewish, seeking to block arms transfers to Israel, garnered 40 Democratic votes in the Senate, but this, from one of the 300 or so fundraising emails I receive every day, didn’t surprise me:
When Bernie introduced his resolution to block these latest arms sales of bombs and bulldozers, he called on Congress to FINALLY show backbone and moral clarity in the wake of horrific violence in Gaza and now Southern Lebanon. But Schumer didn’t just miss the moment – he voted no. That’s a betrayal that will lead to more death and destruction in our name.
Chuck Schumer is the majority leader and he insists on living in a fantasy world in which nothing has changed since 1975. It would be ever so nice if the Democrats would choose a leader who understands where things stand right now.
I should add here that I’m not exactly a fan of any of the countries that surround Israel. Iran is certainly not a country that strikes me as a haven of human rights. But given the situation in that part of the world, we should simply step back and refuse to be a part of any of it while continuing to clearly articulate that opposing what Israel is doing is not equivalent to anti-Semitism. It would not be hard to find plenty of American Jews who would support that position. See, e.g., Bernie Sanders.
